Home arrow About ITFC arrow Impacts and Achievements arrow Completed MSc and PhD projects
Analysing the impacts of bark harvest on Rytigynia kigeziensis in Bwindi Impenetrable National Park, Uganda . MSc thesis by Else Langbroek 2010

In Bwindi Impenetrable National Park (Bwindi), agreements were signed between Uganda Wildlife Authority (UWA) and local people for harvesting of certain non timber forest products (NTFPs) in designated areas called multiple use zones. This is made possible by a programme known as the 'Multiple Use (MU) program' introduced to address conflicts between UWA and local communities in 1994. Very conservative annual harvest quotas (1% of total available and harvestable stock) were set for these plants at first, based on a rapid vulnerability assessment. More recently, random plots were set up in the forest and the quota reset at 3%.

From the early start of the MU program, ITFC was tasked with monitoring the impact of NTFP harvesting in the respective MU zones of Bwindi. A selection of the most vulnerable plants was made for monitoring on an annual basis, to check that harvesting was ecologically sustainable. One of these plants is Rytigynia kigeziensis, a multi-stemmed shrub-tree from which the bark is harvested for medicinal use.

The aim of my study was to evaluate the effects of current bark harvest levels and determine the potential for future harvest, using a matrix modeling approach. Robert Bitariho, senior ITFC researcher in charge of the MU monitoring, kindly availed the existing long term data on R. kigeziensis and allowed me to do the 2010 monitoring with some additional data collection.

Two areas were compared: (1) Ruhija, at an altitude of 2000-2400m where Rytigynia bark harvest is not officially allowed but actual harvest is taking place at relatively high intensity, and (2) the Mpungu and Masya MU zones, at an altitude of 1500-1800m where bark harvest is allowed but is actually below the allowed  quota. 

Analysis of the long term data sets show that the populations of R. kigeziensis are typical of long-lived species which have been harvested for a long time, with most individuals between 6 and 12 mm diameter and declining numbers in larger size classes. The Ruhija population has a larger proportion of thicker stems compared to that of Mpungu and Masya. Bark harvest intensity varied between years and was most abundant for thicker stems in Ruhija. Percentage Similarity index calculations indicate that population structures remained similar over the years of monitoring, indicating that populations were stable. 

Diameter growth ranged from 0.3mm per year for the smallest stems to 3 mm per year for the bigger stems in Ruhija and from 0.5 to 4mm respectively in Mpungu and Masya. Mortality rates were low in both areas, with no evidence of mortality due to bark harvest. Fecundity levels were calculated from the other vital rates, assuming that the populations were stable, because accurate recruitment data were not present. The data did not entirely fit the requirements for matrix model constructions. Individual stems should be identified, marked and monitored over a longer period in order to obtain data on growth, fecundity and mortality. In the MU program, diameter measurements were executed on a yearly basis, but individual stems were not marked and mortality was not recorded. Additional measurements have been made in 2010 to obtain data needed for matrix model construction, but permanently marking all stems will be necessary to be able to improve the models.

A ‘Matrix population model’ was constructed to investigate the population dynamics of R. kigeziensis. Two separate models were constructed to study the effects of current bark harvest levels and the potential for future bark harvest from the species. Population growth rates (λ) calculated with the models were 0,98 to 1,01 for Ruhija and 0,96 to 1,07 for Mpungu and Masya (95% confidence interval), indicating stable populations which do not grow nor decrease in size in the long run. The λ's of Ruhija and Mpungu did not differ significantly. Survival was most important for population maintenance (vital rate with highest elasticity value). This highlights the importance of survival of individual stems, especially of the stems with a diameter of >50 mm, for the population stability of the species. Population growth projections for 10 and 20 years showed that under the current bark harvest regimes, the number of stems per size class remained stable or increased, indicating sustainable harvest levels. However, results of this study should not be considered representative for all populations of R. kigeziensis since our analyses were based on specific populations in specific regions, and data did not fully fit the requirements for matrix model construction.

From September 2010 onwards, Ruhija was officially granted the right to harvest bark of R. kigeziensis in its MU zone.  Bark harvest levels might increase in the Ruhija area due to the new agreement between park management and communities, although it could also decraese since control increases now that harvest is legalized. Continued monitoring of the populations of R. kigeziensis is advised. To improve data collection for the matrix models, permanent marking of individual stems should be implemented in the monitoring program.